Rec Category: Sheppard
Characters: John Sheppard, Rodney McKay, Ronon Dex, Teyla Emmagan, Evan Lorne, Elizabeth Weir, OCs
Pairings: none
Categories: gen
Warnings: none
Author on LJ:
tepring Author's Website: noneLink:A Rock and A Hard Place by TepringSummary by the author:
John Sheppard is who he is. And that usually gets him in trouble, a mission gone horribly wrong, his team is forced to testify against him, his superiors have given him up for lost ... and where the heck is McKay!
Why This Must Be Read:Tepring puts John in a practically unsolvable Dilemma and his decision is pure John Sheppard. Which doesn't mean it's objectively the right thing to do. She puts the spotlight on John's most prominent - and all too human - flaw. A thing that's both: his strength, because it's exactly what inspires the fierce loyalty to him, and his weakness, because it can lead him to understandable, but ethically wrong decisions.
In the end, Tepring lets him off the hook by putting in an unexpected twist and while this could be seen as "cheating" it doesn't feel that way to me because it doesn't make him morally innocent all of a sudden. It doesn't take away from the fact that John's decision was questionable at best but serves just as a way to avoid having him sentenced at the end of the story (which would have put the story firmly in AU-land).
It's quite fascinating to see John wrestle with his own decision, knowing it was the wrong thing to do but having been unable to decide different. This story really hit me because yes, we've seen John making this kind of decisions on screen, albeit not quite to this extent in result.
( snippet of fic )