stargateficrec | Speaking O'Neill by Jaz (PG)

Speaking O'Neill by Jaz

Rec Category: Jack & Daniel Friendship
Pairing: Jack & Daniel (friendship)
Category: Episode Tag (for New Order)
Warning: No warnings, but spoilers through New Order (Season 8); The author rates this story PG, but I might even give it a G rating.
Author on LJ: I don't know.
Author's Website: Jaz's page at Stargate Fan
Link: Speaking O'Neill

Why This Must Be Read: This story captures the Jack & Daniel friendship with characterizations that are spot-on, with banter and dialogue that "sound" like the characters, and with just the right amount of emotion and humor to make it uniquely Jack and Daniel. This is a feel-good kind of story that will make you chuckle, perhaps get a very slight bit misty-eyed, and then give you a warm, fuzzy feeling inside that leaves you feeling happy about just about everything. It's one of my all-time favorite stories of any kind. I hope you'll all enjoy it, too.

P.S. This is my first fic rec. Please let me know if there's anything I didn't do quite right. Sorry about the goof of sending the other message before I'd put anything into it.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

your fic rec looked fine to me, and I know how you feel. yesterday I spent 1 hour on my first fic rec to this list. It too me forever to figure out how much I needed to write for the review and triple checking all the links. I don't think it's possible to edit your message if you post it incorrectly. Anyway, I think most people are laid back about the recs.

My main worry is the actual reviewing part. In real life when I try telling people about a wonderful story I read, I normally seem to make them want to run far away from the story instead of reading it. And i think that fear tranlates to online fic reviews too. So I feel that the less said is better. but everyone here seems to write these really long reviews.

Thanks! I was able to delete it with advice from...eh! I forgot to note the name. Please forgive me, but accept my thanks. :-) You go to your entry and click on "edit entry" (the pencil icon). There's a button at the bottom that says "delete entry." I never noticed that before.

And yes, I was so nervous posting for the first time! :-)

I was also worried about the reviewing part. I even wrote to

angelsgracie about that, and she was very nice and helpful and reassuring. My problem with reviewing is just thinking of something to say. A lot of times when I send feedback, I just say, "Thanks for the story."

Anyway, I'm new at this, too, but I, personally, don't mind shorter reviews. Once I get going, I tend to say too much about most things, so I don't know how I'll do overall. Speaking O'Neill is one of my favorite stories, though, so probably the easiest one I'll write.

Sadly, saying "the story rocks" just doesn't say much about the story. :) Though I agree, it is easier to write about a story if you really love it. The hard part is not giving away the story while you write about it.

The good news, is that since no one else volunteered to take this category they can't really complain if they don't like my reviewing style. Not that I'm going to do a crappy job on purpose. I just don't want to do a disservice to the stories I'm recommending.

but anyway good luck finding three more stories this month. :) I look forward to reading what you recommend.

Sadly, saying "the story rocks" just doesn't say much about the story. :)

Exactly! LOL As you said, though, it's hard to think of what to say about a story without giving too much away or making the story sound stupid when it's a really, really good story.

Another thing is that sometimes when I try to give detailed feedback and pick out something that I felt really made the story stand out, I say it in a way that the author then thinks I didn't like it! LOL I don't know why that happens, because I think I'm saying why I *like a story, but it just doesn't read that way or something. So that's another reason that, like you, I tend not to say too much about the details of a story any more. :-)

Thanks for the wishes. Good luck to you, too! :-) (Also, I love your icon.)

I loved it too. :) nice rec. I love it when authors can write Jack. :)

Thanks! It's good to know that at least one person read it and liked it. :-)

Speaking O'Neill by Jaz (PG)

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

read the story

Re: read the story